Showing posts with label Electoral College. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Electoral College. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 6, 2012

The lesser of two evils?

If the Green Party's presidential candidates had been listed on the Oklahoma ballot, I would have voted for Jill Stein and Cheri Honkala.

Given Oklahoma's extremely restrictive ballot access laws, the only two choices I had were Mitt Romney and Barack Obama. Obama is the lesser of two evils by a large margin. Romney demonstrates a complete lack of core integrity, a willingness to shift from progressive to extreme conservative opinions based on whatever is popular at the moment, and an alliance with the most regressive economic and political forces in the United States.

Nevertheless, I wish I'd had the option to vote for Jill Stein today. For one thing, living in the reddest of red states, I know that Oklahoma will go solidly for Romney. Given the reality of the way the Electoral College operates, a vote for anyone else is a protest vote. I would like my protest vote to be for the candidate I prefer.

As Doug Henwood put it in a recent post for The Nation:
...I wish, just once, an endorsement of a Democratic presidential candidate coming from the left would mull over some serious structural issues that are at stake.

There are certain eternally recurrent features of these endorsement editorials, and they are depressing. The shortcomings of this year’s Democrat are acknowledged, only to be dismissed, because this is always the most important election since 1932, or maybe 1860. If the Democrats lose, brownshirts will move into the Oval Office. It will be repression and immiseration at home and aggressive war abroad. Sure, there will be some repression, immiseration and war even if the Dem wins, but see above re dismissal of shortcomings.

The persistence of the pattern is no exaggeration. Here’s something from a 1967 essay by Hal Draper on the imminent 1968 election: “Every time the liberal labor left has made noises about its dissatisfaction with what Washington was trickling through, all the Democrats had to do was bring out the bogy of the Republican right. The lib-labs would then swoon, crying ‘The fascists are coming!’ and vote for the Lesser Evil.”

And what is the consequence of that swoon? Draper’s answer: “the Democrats have learned well that they have the lib-lab vote in their back pocket, and that therefore the forces to be appeased are those forces to the right.” Almost every editorial urging a vote for this year’s Dem will lament the rightward move of our politics without ever considering the contribution of such calls to the process.

In other words, the Democrats will continue to ignore and disrespect the progressive vote, because they've learned that they can get away with it.

I would much prefer to have the opportunity to vote for candidates who actually respect my views.



Saturday, November 1, 2008

The sordid history of the Electoral College (final part of a three-part series)

(You may also want to read Part I and Part II of this series.)

I'm going to tell two competing stories about the history of the US Electoral College. One of these stories was written in 1992 by William C. Kimberling, who was then the deputy director of the Federal Election Commission's Office of Election Administration. The other story was written by brothers Akhil Reed Amar and Vikram David Amar for the FindLaw web site.

In Kimberling's rather quaint version of the story, we have a much smaller nation than today--just 4 million people, spread out along the Atlantic seaboard, residing in "thirteen large and small States jealous of their own rights and suspicious of any central government" They believed that "political parties were mischievous if not downright evil," and "felt that gentlemen should not campaign for public office."

The framers of the Constitution considered having Congress choose the president, but rejected that idea because it would break down the separation of powers between the executive and legislative branches of government. They considered having state legislatures select the president, but feared that this would erode federal authority.

Having a direct popular election of the president was also rejected. Writes Kimberling:
Direct election was rejected not because the Framers of the Constitution doubted public intelligence but rather because they feared that without sufficient information about candidat es from outside their State, people would naturally vote for a "favorite son" from their own State or region. At worst, no president would emerge with a popular majority sufficient to govern the whole country. At best, the choice of president would always be decided by the largest, most populous States with little regard for the smaller ones.
In contrast, the Electoral College would be made up of "the most knowledgeable and informed individuals from each State to select the president based solely on merit and without regard to State of origin or political party."

According to the Amar brothers, the real motivation behind this scheme was much less noble:
The biggest flaw in standard civics accounts of the electoral college is that they never mention the real demon dooming direct national election in 1787 and 1803: slavery.

At the Philadelphia convention, the visionary Pennsylvanian James Wilson proposed direct national election of the President. But in a key speech on July 19, the savvy Virginian James Madison suggested that such a system would prove unacceptable to the South: "The right of suffrage was much more diffusive in the Northern than the Southern States; and the latter could have no influence in the election on the score of Negroes."

In other words, in a direct election system, the North would outnumber the South, whose many slaves (more than half a million in all) of course could not vote. But the electoral college-a prototype of which Madison proposed in this same speech-instead let each southern state count its slaves, albeit with a two-fifths discount, in computing its share of the overall electoral college.

The Amars add that the electoral college system also discouraged states from granting women the right to vote. Under a system of direct popular elections, the more voters a state had, the more its citizens would influence national elections. With the electoral college, what mattered was how many people lived in each state, not how many of those people could vote.

Kimberling and the Amar brothers agree that the method of conducting presidential elections outlined in the original constitution was transformed by the Twelfth Amendment . Originally, each elector cast two votes for president. The man with the most votes became president, and the runner-up became vice president. When there were no political parties, this system was workable.

But in the election of 1800, two rudimentary political parties--the Federalists led by John Adams and the Democratic-Republicans led by Thomas--squared off against each other. The Democratic-Republicans came out on top. As the Amar brothers note, "without the extra electoral college votes generated by slavery, the mostly southern states that supported Jefferson would not have sufficed to give him a majority...Thomas Jefferson metaphorically rode into the executive mansion on the backs of slaves."

But there was at least one serious glitch in the process. Thomas Jefferson and Aaron Burr, both representing the Democratic-Republicans, came out with the same number of electoral votes. Kimberling points out that "The tie was resolved by the House of Representatives in Jefferson's favor -- but only after 36 tries and some serious political dealings which were considered unseemly at the time."

The Twelfth Amendment was written to keep such a thing from happening again. It left the South's unfair electoral advantage in place. But it accommodated political parties by changing the system so that electors each cast one vote for president and one vote for vice president.

With the establishment of nationwide political parties, presidential candidates began to run nationwide campaigns for direct voter approval. Given this situation, the Amar brothers say,
Americans must ask themselves whether we want to maintain this peculiar institution in the twenty-first century.

After all, most millennial Americans no longer believe in slavery or sexism. We do not believe that voters lack proper information about national candidates. We do not believe that a national figure claiming a national mandate is unacceptably dangerous. What we do believe is that each American is an equal citizen. We celebrate the idea of one person, one vote-an idea undermined by the electoral college.
Well, maybe not quite everyone celebrates the idea of one person, one vote. Republican operatives are prone to using a variety of shady tactics to suppress voter turnout. Over at Truthdig, Bill Boyarsky argues that efforts to intimidate voters, challenge their eligibility, and subject them to long lines might prove decisive if the election is close. It seems to me that such tactics would be less effective if they had to be applied nationwide, in every precinct, rather than in a few swing states.

The Amar brothers provide more reasons for abolishing the Electoral College and a practical plan for making it happen. As someone who would like to promote democracy and resist the rule of manipulative elites, moving toward direct popular election of the president seems like a good step to take.

Friday, October 31, 2008

Should we drop out of Electoral College? (second part of a three-part series)

So. In the United States, we have this goofy, complicated way of electing the president. In every state, voters go to the polls and vote for a list of people who promise to vote for a particular candidate when the real vote comes up in the Electoral College. (For details, see Part I of this series.)

Is this a good idea or not?

Although the United States was a very different country in 1789 when the Constitution was ratified, some folks argue that the method of electing a president that was adopted then still works well. William Kimberling--in an essay written in 1992, but widely circulated on the Web today--takes this position.

According to Kimberling, if presidents were elected by majority vote of the entire population, "presidents would be selected either through the domination of one populous region over the others or through the domination of large metropolitan areas over the rural ones." By contrast, the Electoral College system requires candidates to gain support from many regions of the country.

Kimberling also argues that "the votes of even small minorities in a State may make the difference between winning all of that State's electoral votes or none of that State's electoral votes." He says this gives "ethnic minority groups and other special interests" more power than they would have otherwise.

Kimberling seems to contradict himself with his next argument, that the Electoral College protects the political stability of the nation by strongly encouraging a two-party system For one thing, "it would be extremely difficult for a new or minor party to win enough popular votes in enough States to have a chance of winning the presidency."
In addition to protecting the presidency from impassioned but transitory third party movements, the practical effect of the Electoral College (along with the single-member district system of representation in the Congress) is to virtually force third party movements into one of the two major political parties. Conversely, the major parties have every incentive to absorb minor party movements in their continual attempt to win popular majorities in the States. In this process of assimilation, third party movements are obliged to compromise their more radical views if they hope to attain any of their more generally acceptable objectives. Thus we end up with two large, pragmatic political parties which tend to the center of public opinion rather than dozens of smaller political parties catering to divergent and sometimes extremist views. In other words, such a system forces political coalitions to occur within the political parties rather than within the government.

Stability and moderation sound like good things. But couldn't you also say that this system allows powerful elites to limit the influence of new movements and new ideas and keep their grip on power? Maybe this why there often seems to be very little substantive difference between the two major parties?

Whoops. Looks like my radical bias is slipping in here.

But you don't have to be a radical in order to advocate doing away with the Electoral College. A New York Times editorial from 2004 argues persuasively for just that course of action. (A more recent commentary in the Houston Chronicle makes similar points.)

The Times points out that the presidential candidates focus their campaigns only in those states where the vote is likely to be close. Surefire :"blue" (Democratic) or "red" (Republican) states are ignored by the presidential candidates. Voters in those states are likely to be discouraged from going to the polls, because whether in the majority or the minority, they have good reason to believe that their votes don't matter. (Oklahoma, though not mentioned specifically by the Times, is one of those states.)

The Times argues that Presidential candidates focus on issues important in a small number of swing states, and ignore issues that are of importance elsewhere. As an example, the interests of Cuban Americans get a lot of attention from the candidates--because most Cuban Americans live in the swing state of Florida. Because most people from Puerto Rico live in heavily Democratic states, their concerns are mostly ignored

Furthermore,
The arcane rules governing the Electoral College have the potential to create havoc if things go wrong. Electors are not required to vote for the candidates they are pledged to, and if the vote is close in the Electoral College, a losing candidate might well be able to persuade a small number of electors to switch sides. Because there are an even number of electors -- one for every senator and House member of the states, and three for the District of Columbia -- the Electoral College vote can end in a tie...In the case of a tie, the election goes to the House of Representatives, where each state delegation gets one vote -- one for Wyoming's 500,000 residents and one for California's 35.5 million.
The Times concludes that "The small states are already significantly overrepresented in the Senate, which more than looks out for their interests. And there is no interest higher than making every vote count."

Personally, before I started this set of blog posts about the Electoral College, I was neutral about whether it was best to keep it or best to get rid of it. It's true that if we had gone by the popular vote, Al Gore would have been elected president in 2000. But it's also true that even under the Electoral College system, if not for some very questionable practices in Florida, Gore would have won that state, and also the presidency.

But once I started learning more about the history of the Electoral College, I found myself becoming convinced that we really need to get rid of it. For more information about this history, see the final part of this series.